5.19.2007

Immigration debate - WSJ

Immigration Opening - The Bush-Kennedy proposal's vices and virtues

Excerpt:

On the plus side, the bill addresses the 12 million undocumented aliens living in the U.S. by providing a way for most to obtain legal status with minimal disruption to their lives or employers. In return for reporting to authorities, paying a $5,000 fine, passing a criminal-background check and making a "touch back" visit to their home country, illegal aliens would be eligible for a "Z" visa allowing them to keep working here.

Restrictionists are calling this "amnesty," but they were going to slap that label on anything this side of mass deportation. The public is understandably upset about the presence of so many illegal aliens in the U.S. But there is no evidence that voters want millions of foreign families--many of whom have been here for decades and have American children--uprooted and forcibly removed from the country. The restrictionist wing of the GOP simply wants no new immigration, and "amnesty" is merely a political slogan to kill any reform.

Comment: A better read than my posting from yesterday. Interesting that the O.J. calls it the "The Bush-Kennedy proposal". I agree completely with the O.J. comments on the "amnesty" label.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Any anonymous comments with links will be rejected. Please do not comment off-topic